No Bake Eggnog Pie Recipe With a Custard-Like Filling Straight from the Fridge

Old-fashioned comfort, chilled and spiced just right

Eggnog pie is one of those quiet desserts. It doesn’t ask for much attention. No layers, no crackly tops. Just a cool slice of spiced pudding cream, resting in a graham crust, tasting of holiday gatherings and soft winter evenings. I’ve been making some version of this pie since the late ’70s. This one is simpler than most. No eggs to temper, no stove to watch. The filling thickens right in the bowl.

If you’ve ever made a custard pie, you already know how softly egg-based desserts can speak. This one uses eggnog instead of milk, and instant pudding instead of eggs. That may sound modern, but the feeling it gives is old as time. Cold, spiced, and gentle. A refrigerator pie that slices smooth, tastes deep, and reminds you of December evenings even if you’re eating it in July.

What Makes Eggnog Pie Soothing

This pie uses full-fat eggnog, the kind that coats a spoon. That thickness gives the pudding a texture almost like custard, which is why many call this an Eggnog Custard Pie even though there’s no baking involved. The vanilla pudding mix thickens the eggnog into something sliceable, while the whipped topping adds softness. No gelatin. No water baths. Just mix and fold.

The crust gives a quiet crunch. I usually use graham crackers, crushed fine and mixed with melted butter. Some people like to bake it for a few minutes to firm it up, but you don’t have to. The cold from the fridge sets it just fine. If you’ve made chocolate pudding pie before, the method here will feel familiar—but the flavor is entirely its own.

Choosing the Right Eggnog for Pie Filling

In my notes, I’ve tried both store-bought eggnog and homemade. The homemade version was thinner and didn’t hold the filling as well. Store-bought, full-fat eggnog works better for this. Avoid anything labeled “light” or dairy-free—it won’t set the same way. I keep a note in the margin of my recipe card: “use the thick one.” That’s always helped.

For anyone wondering about flavor, eggnog tastes like vanilla, nutmeg, and the memory of old Christmas records playing in the kitchen. It’s what gives this pie its quiet depth.

Making the Graham Cracker Crust

You’ll need fine crumbs and melted butter. I press it into a glass pie plate with the back of a measuring cup. If I want a firmer crust, I bake it for five minutes. If I don’t feel like turning on the oven, I let it chill in the fridge instead. Both work. If the crust cracks when you press it in, don’t worry. The filling will cover it.

There’s something comforting about crusts like this. No rolling. No flour on your hands. Just press, chill, and go.

Mixing and Folding the Eggnog Pudding

Use two boxes of instant vanilla pudding. Pour the eggnog in slowly, whisk until smooth, then let it sit. It thickens on its own in a few minutes. I usually fold in the whipped topping after that. Don’t stir too hard. Use a spatula and take your time. I always think of it as coaxing the air to stay inside.

If you’re making this around the holidays, and you have fresh nutmeg on hand, grate a little on top. It’s stronger than the pre-ground kind. But either will do. Some years I’ve used a cinnamon sprinkle instead.

Letting It Chill — And Why Time Matters

This isn’t a pie you slice an hour after making. It needs a long chill. I give it at least four hours, but overnight is better. I’ve left notes in my old green notebook: “Don’t rush the fridge.” The flavors settle as it chills, and the texture holds better the next day.

If you’re looking at other Christmas pies recipes, you’ll find some that take more work. This one gives you time back. You can prep it in the morning and serve it in the evening, or make it a full day ahead of a gathering.

Serving Notes and Slice Tips

I use a sharp knife dipped in warm water to cut clean slices. Wipe the blade between each one. That keeps the layers neat. A big spoon of whipped cream on top softens the look and adds a cloud of sweetness. Don’t skip the nutmeg—it carries the eggnog forward.

If the first slice falls apart, that’s fine. My first slice always has a mind of its own. I scoop it into a dish and enjoy it standing by the sink, usually while the rest of the pie sets even firmer.

Other Eggnog Dessert Recipes to Try

Over the years, I’ve written down versions of eggnog cookies and eggnog cake recipes in the margins of my old recipe cards. But I always come back to this pie. It’s gentle. It keeps well. It feels like something passed down, even if you’re making it for the first time.

If you’re fond of nut-based pies, pecan pie is another I’ve returned to often during the holidays. But for something cold and quiet, this one stays in my December binder every year.

Share a Slice or Ask a Question

If you make this pie, I’d love to hear how it goes. Leave a note in the comments, or pin it to remember for later. If you run into a cracked crust or a soft set, don’t worry. These things happen even in old kitchens like mine. The pie still serves sweet, and no one notices once it’s on their plate.

And Chloe, if you’re reading this—yes, I still use that handwritten card you sent me years ago. The ink is fading, but the flavor holds.

Continue to Content

Yield: 8 slices

Eggnog Pie Recipe

No Ratings

Print

Creamy and lightly spiced, this no-bake eggnog pie brings together rich vanilla pudding, whipped topping, and full-fat eggnog for a smooth, custard-like texture. A graham cracker crust adds a sweet crunch, and a dusting of nutmeg finishes it with a familiar holiday note. It’s easy to assemble and sets in the fridge, making it a stress-free dessert for gatherings or quiet nights.

Prep Time 20 minutes

Additional Time 4 hours

Total Time 4 hours 20 minutes

Ingredients

• FOR THE CRUST
• 1 ½ cups graham cracker crumbs
• 6 tablespoons unsalted butter, melted
• FOR THE FILLING
• 2 (3.4-ounce) boxes instant vanilla pudding mix
• 2 cups full-fat eggnog
• 1 (8-ounce) tub frozen whipped topping, thawed
• FOR TOPPING
• Additional whipped topping or freshly whipped cream
• Ground nutmeg, for garnish

Instructions

1. PREPARE THE CRUST: In a medium bowl, stir together the graham cracker crumbs and melted butter until evenly combined. Press the mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of a 9-inch pie dish. Chill for 30 minutes, or bake at 350°F (177°C) for 5–7 minutes if a firmer texture is desired. Let cool completely before filling.
2. MIX THE PUDDING BASE: In a large mixing bowl, whisk together the instant vanilla pudding mix and eggnog until smooth. Let the mixture stand for 5 minutes to thicken slightly.
3. FOLD IN WHIPPED TOPPING: Gently fold the thawed whipped topping into the pudding mixture using a spatula. Scoop from the bottom and fold over the top, repeating until no streaks remain. Avoid overmixing to preserve the light texture.
4. ASSEMBLE THE PIE: Pour the filling into the prepared crust and smooth the top with the back of a spoon or an offset spatula.
5. CHILL THE PIE: Refrigerate the pie for at least 4 hours, or preferably overnight, to allow it to set fully.
6. ADD TOPPING: Just before serving, spread additional whipped topping or freshly whipped cream over the chilled pie. Dust with ground nutmeg for flavor and presentation.
7. SLICE AND SERVE: For clean slices, use a sharp knife dipped in warm water and wipe the blade between each cut. Serve chilled.

Notes

For best texture, use thick, full-fat eggnog. Avoid substituting cook-and-serve pudding or gelatin, as these will change the consistency. Freshly grated nutmeg adds more flavor than pre-ground, but either can be used.

Nutrition Information:

Yield:

8

Serving Size:

1
Amount Per Serving: Calories: 256Total Fat: 14gSaturated Fat: 8gTrans Fat: 0gUnsaturated Fat: 5gCholesterol: 61mgSodium: 287mgCarbohydrates: 30gFiber: 1gSugar: 21gProtein: 4g