Home » Christmas » Fantasy Fudge
A leaning stack of four squares of chocolate fantasy fudge with walnut pieces on crumpled parchment on black marble, a fallen walnut beside it and a foil-lined pan of cut fudge behind.

How to Make Old-Fashioned Fantasy Fudge in One Saucepan

A hand holding a square of chocolate walnut fudge with a bite taken from the corner, above a foil-lined pan of freshly spread fudge with swirls on top, around a red panel reading Christmas Fantasy Fudge, 7 Ingredients, 40 Pieces.

Fantasy fudge is the creamy, sliceable chocolate fudge that shows up in Christmas tins every December, the one made with a jar of marshmallow creme. It cuts into clean squares with walnuts all through it, and it stays soft without ever turning sticky or grainy.

The one step that makes or breaks it is the boil. Sugar, butter and evaporated milk need a full rolling boil for 4 minutes, stirred the whole time, until the syrup reaches 234°F (112°C). Off the heat, the chocolate chips and marshmallow creme go in and cool it down just enough to set firm. The whole job takes about 25 minutes at the stove, one 3-quart saucepan and one 9×13 pan, plus 4 hours to set. One batch makes 40 pieces, enough for 5 or 6 gift tins.

At a Glance

  • Yield: 40 pieces, about 3 pounds (1.4 kg) of fudge
  • Pan: a 9×13-inch (23×33 cm) pan lined with foil
  • Saucepan: heavy-bottomed, at least 3 quarts (3 liters)
  • Time: 10 minutes prep, 15 minutes at the stove, 4 hours to set
  • Difficulty: easy, as long as you can stand at the stove and stir for 4 minutes
  • Key technique: a full rolling boil for 4 minutes, or to 234°F (112°C) on a candy thermometer

Why the 4-Minute Boil Matters

The boil sets the texture of the finished fudge. Sugar dissolved in butter and milk only firms up once enough water cooks off. At 234°F (112°C), the soft-ball stage, the syrup holds about 15 percent water. That is the amount that gives fudge you can cut but that still feels creamy on the tongue. Stop at 225°F (107°C) and the pan stays soft in the middle for days. Go past 240°F (116°C) and the fudge sets firm and crumbly at the edges.

The marshmallow creme is why this recipe is forgiving. Old-fashioned fudge needs careful cooling and beating to keep the sugar crystals small. Here the marshmallow creme gets in the way of the sugar crystals, so the fudge sets smooth even if you skip the thermometer. The 12 ounces (340 g) of chocolate chips add the cocoa butter that makes it firm at room temperature.

Constant stirring matters for a plainer reason. Evaporated milk scorches quickly on the bottom of the pan once the syrup passes 220°F (104°C). A wooden spoon or a heatproof spatula that scrapes the bottom and corners every few seconds keeps brown flecks and a burnt taste out of the fudge.

Ingredient Notes

Labeled ingredients for fantasy fudge from above on black marble: a bowl of sugar, an open can of evaporated milk, a bowl of chocolate chips, a stick and a half of butter, a jar of marshmallow creme with a spoon, a bowl of walnuts and a bottle of vanilla.
  • Granulated sugar: 3 cups (600 g). It is most of the structure, so measure it level. Brown sugar makes a softer, caramel-tasting fudge that takes longer to set.
  • Butter: 3/4 cup (170 g), salted or unsalted. Salted butter gives a rounder chocolate flavor. Margarine and spreads hold too much water, and the fudge may never set.
  • Evaporated milk: 2/3 cup (160 ml), about one 5-ounce can. Do not swap in sweetened condensed milk; it adds too much sugar and burns before the syrup reaches temperature. Whole milk works only with a thermometer, because it needs a longer boil to reach 234°F.
  • Semi-sweet chocolate chips: 12 ounces (340 g, 2 cups). Milk chocolate chips make a sweeter, softer fudge, and half semi-sweet and half bittersweet gives a darker one.
  • Marshmallow creme: one 7-ounce (198 g) jar. It must be creme, not mini marshmallows: marshmallows need heat to melt and leave lumps in a cooling pan.
  • Walnuts: 1 cup (120 g), chopped to about pea size. Pecans work the same way, or leave the nuts out.
  • Vanilla extract: 1 teaspoon, stirred in last so the heat does not cook off its flavor.

Cooking the Fudge Syrup

Get everything ready before you light the stove, because the second half moves fast. Line the 9×13 pan with foil, letting it hang over the long sides, and butter the foil. Open the jar of marshmallow creme, chop the walnuts and measure the chocolate chips into a bowl.

Put the sugar, butter and evaporated milk in the saucepan over medium heat. Stir until the butter melts and the mixture comes to a boil, about 5 minutes. When it reaches a full rolling boil, one that keeps bubbling while you stir, set a timer for 4 minutes and stir without stopping. A clip-on candy thermometer should read 234°F (112°C) at the end. If it reads lower, keep boiling and check every 30 seconds.

Doneness Cues Without a Thermometer

A cold-water test tells you when the syrup is ready. Drop half a teaspoon into a glass of very cold water: at the soft-ball stage it gathers into a soft ball you can pick up and flatten between two fingers. If it spreads into threads, boil 30 seconds longer and test again.

Take the pan off the heat, add the chocolate chips and stir until they melt completely, about 1 minute. Add the marshmallow creme and vanilla and beat with the spoon until no white streaks are left, then stir in the walnuts.

A steel saucepan on a folded linen towel holding glossy melted chocolate fudge mixture with white streaks of marshmallow creme and chopped walnuts on top, a wooden spoon resting in it and a jar of marshmallow creme beside it.

The mixture should look glossy and thick, like stiff frosting, and fall off the spoon in heavy ribbons. Pour it into the lined pan right away and spread it to the corners with an offset spatula. It starts to set within 5 minutes, so do not stop to scrape the saucepan clean.

Uncut chocolate fudge spread in a foil-lined 9x13 pan with spatula swirls on top and a few walnut pieces showing, an offset spatula with a smear of fudge lying beside the pan.

Setting and Cutting 40 Squares

Let the fudge set at room temperature for 4 hours, or until it feels firm when you press the center. The fridge speeds it up to about 2 hours but can leave a dull, sweaty surface. Lift the whole slab out with the foil and set it on a cutting board.

Cut 5 strips along the short side and 8 across the long side for 40 pieces of about 1 3/4 by 1 1/2 inches (4.5 x 4 cm). A large chef’s knife dipped in hot water and wiped dry between cuts gives clean edges. Press straight down instead of sawing, which drags the walnuts and tears the top.

A foil-lined pan of chocolate walnut fudge cut into squares with three pieces lifted out and set on the black marble in front, a chef's knife lying below them.

Troubleshooting Fantasy Fudge

ProblemCauseFix
Soft and sticky after 6 hoursBoiled too short or the boil was not rollingScrape it back into the pan with 1/4 cup (60 ml) evaporated milk and boil to 234°F again
Dry and crumblyBoiled past 240°F (116°C)Serve it as crumbles over ice cream; next time start timing only at a full boil
Grainy textureSugar crystals on the pan walls fell back inBrush the pan walls with a wet pastry brush during the boil
Brown flecks, burnt tasteMilk scorched on the bottomUse a heavier pan, medium heat, and scrape the bottom while stirring
Lumps of whiteMarshmallow creme not fully beaten inBeat a few seconds longer before pouring; it melts in the hot mixture

Swaps and Variations

  • Peanut butter fantasy fudge: swap the chocolate chips for 12 ounces (340 g) of peanut butter chips and leave out the walnuts.
  • Peppermint: use 1/2 teaspoon peppermint extract instead of the vanilla and scatter crushed candy canes on top while the fudge is still warm.
  • Rocky road: fold 1 cup (50 g) mini marshmallows in with the walnuts once the mixture has cooled for 2 minutes, so they stay whole.
  • Thicker pieces: use a 9-inch (23 cm) square pan. The fudge is about 1 inch (2.5 cm) thick and takes 5 to 6 hours to set.

If you want a white chocolate version, our Christmas fudge uses sweetened condensed milk and needs no boil. For a tray of mixed candy, fantasy fudge sits well next to peppermint bark, dark chocolate bark and candied pecans.

Storing and Gifting the Fudge

Fantasy fudge keeps for 2 weeks at room temperature in an airtight tin, with parchment between the layers so the pieces do not stick together. In the fridge it lasts about 3 weeks, though it firms up; let it stand for 20 minutes before serving. For longer storage, wrap the uncut slab in plastic wrap and foil and freeze it for up to 3 months, then thaw it in the fridge overnight before cutting.

A round red gift tin lined with parchment and filled with squares of chocolate walnut fudge, the red lid leaning against the back and a piece of red and white twine on the marble.

For gifts, 6 to 8 pieces fill a small tin, so one pan covers 5 or 6 gifts. Pack the fudge only once it has fully set, and add a treat with crunch, such as Rolo pretzel bites or a bag of Christmas puppy chow, to fill the gaps.

Questions About Fantasy Fudge

Is this the original fantasy fudge recipe?

It follows the classic version from the marshmallow creme jar: 3 cups of sugar, 3/4 cup of butter, evaporated milk, 12 ounces of chocolate chips, a 7-ounce jar of creme, walnuts and vanilla, boiled for 4 minutes.

Can I use a larger jar of marshmallow creme?

A 13-ounce jar makes the fudge softer and sweeter. If that is all you have, measure out about half of it, roughly 1 1/2 cups.

Why did my fudge not set?

Almost always the syrup did not reach 234°F (112°C), usually because the 4 minutes were counted before the boil was rolling. You can reboil it with a splash of evaporated milk.

Can I double the recipe?

Make two separate batches. A double batch needs a much larger pan and a longer boil, and it is hard to stir fast enough to keep it from scorching.

More Christmas Candy and Treats

For more homemade gifts, try Oreo balls or white chocolate limoncello truffles, or pick from our list of easy no-bake Christmas treats. For a full holiday platter, the Christmas cookie recipes and easy Christmas desserts cover the rest of the table.

A red gift tin of chocolate walnut fudge squares on parchment, above a foil-lined pan of fudge cut into a grid with three pieces set in front, with a cream panel reading Christmas Marshmallow Fudge, Edible Gift, Makes 40.
Yield: 40 pieces

Fantasy Fudge

A leaning stack of four squares of chocolate fantasy fudge with walnut pieces on crumpled parchment on black marble, a fallen walnut beside it and a foil-lined pan of cut fudge behind.

Made it? Tap the stars to rate it.

No Ratings

Fantasy fudge is the old-fashioned marshmallow creme fudge: creamy chocolate squares packed with walnuts that slice cleanly and stay soft for days. Sugar, butter and evaporated milk boil hard for 4 minutes, to 234°F (112°C), then semi-sweet chocolate chips, a jar of marshmallow creme and vanilla get beaten in off the heat. The creme keeps the sugar from crystallizing, so the fudge sets smooth with no beating or careful cooling. One 9x13 pan makes 40 pieces for Christmas tins, cookie trays and gifts.

Prep Time 10 minutes
Cook Time 15 minutes
Additional Time 4 hours
Total Time 4 hours 25 minutes

Ingredients

  • 3 cups granulated sugar (600 g)
  • 3/4 cup butter (170 g), salted or unsalted
  • 2/3 cup evaporated milk (160 ml), about one 5-ounce can
  • 12 ounces semi-sweet chocolate chips (340 g, 2 cups)
  • 1 jar marshmallow creme (7 ounces, 198 g)
  • 1 cup chopped walnuts (120 g)
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract

Instructions

  1. PREP: Line a 9x13-inch pan with foil, letting it hang over the long sides, and butter the foil. Measure the chocolate chips, open the marshmallow creme and chop the walnuts.
  2. BOIL: In a heavy 3-quart saucepan, combine the sugar, butter and evaporated milk. Stir over medium heat until the mixture comes to a full rolling boil.
  3. COOK: Boil for 4 minutes, stirring constantly, until a candy thermometer reads 234°F (112°C).
  4. MELT: Remove from the heat. Stir in the chocolate chips until completely melted.
  5. MIX: Add the marshmallow creme and vanilla and beat until no white streaks remain. Stir in the walnuts.
  6. SPREAD: Pour into the prepared pan right away and spread to the corners.
  7. SET: Let stand at room temperature for about 4 hours, until firm.
  8. CUT: Lift the fudge out with the foil and cut into 5 rows by 8 rows, 40 pieces. Store airtight.

Notes

  • Start the 4-minute timer only once the mixture is at a full rolling boil; it should read 234°F (112°C).
  • No thermometer: a drop of syrup in cold water should form a soft ball you can flatten.
  • Stir constantly and scrape the bottom so the evaporated milk does not scorch.
  • Use marshmallow creme, not mini marshmallows, or the fudge will be lumpy.
  • Keeps 2 weeks in an airtight tin at room temperature, 3 months frozen as an uncut slab.

Nutrition Information:

Yield:

40

Serving Size:

1

Amount Per Serving: Calories: 172Total Fat: 8gSaturated Fat: 4gTrans Fat: 0gUnsaturated Fat: 4gCholesterol: 10mgSodium: 34mgCarbohydrates: 25gFiber: 1gSugar: 23gProtein: 1g

Read next

★ Made it? Tap the stars to rate it

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*